E*Trade: The Right Stuff “Baby”?

Written by Anthony Gulino (contact - e-mail) -- June 27th, 2008 | Recommend This

Everyone’s favorite investor in diapers is back as the E*Trade Baby makes a new appearance promoting Mobile E*Trade Pro. By now I’m sure most of us have seen those popular E*TRADE Baby advertisements either on television or online. There are now three ads with the mobile variation joining the E*Trade Banking Baby and E*Trade Trading Baby. The previous versions have both gained over a million views on YouTube since the first release during this year’s Super Bowl.

While airing a Super Bowl advertisement likely increases awareness for each advertiser, there is the inevitable debate over whether Super Bowl ads really pay off in terms of actual revenue. In the case of E*Trade, the question is whether the company managed to attract new customers post-airing of the Baby ads.

We first looked into how E*Trade has performed in terms of site traffic to its home page since launching the Super Bowl ad. Although the advertisements received great reviews, the campaigns did not result in increased traffic to etrade.com. Below we see that in February and March of 2008, visitors to E*Trade actually decreased 10% compared to February 2008. What makes this decline even more interesting is the fact that in January traffic increased 4% over the previous month. The subsequent decline continued into April by a modest 3%.

While on the surface it may look as if the ad campaign was not effective for E*Trade, one has to look deeper to see the real story. The idea of quality over quantity comes into play here. While monthly site traffic to etrade.com decreased after the E*Trade Baby made his first appearance, the quality of the traffic increased greatly. Below is a measure of velocity at etrade.com using the Super Bowl (February 3, 2008) as the starting point. Velocity measures the attention (or time spent on a site) and how it changes compared to one point in time. For example, during the first few days after the Super Bowl, attention increased nearly 200% at etrade.com. This shows that even though fewer people were going to etrade.com, those that did visit were spending more time engaging with the site than people that visited prior to the big game.

In the modern era all too often we see trendy Super Bowl ads that might be a hit with the public, but do not generate results on the bottom line. If someone were to look just at the traffic for E*Trade they might think this is another example of such a flop. By looking at the bigger picture however, it is apparent that the campaign was successful when it came to getting people more engaged with the brand which is a win in my book. E*Trade certainly seems happy with the results since they are willing to invest more in having this wise cracking infant be their public face.


Analyze more domains: + +

Done reading? subscribe: To get an automatic feed of all future posts subscribe here, or to receive them via email enter your email address in the box in the right column.

Link to This Post:     


Comments

RSS feed for comments on this post.
  1. Ling

    Like Carls Jr Burger ad with Paris Hilton? What were the stats for that one?

  2. ETFC = $16 - $32

    ETFC current earnings estimates for 2011 are for $1.08/share.

    http://earnings.nasdaq.com/earnings/earn…

    At a PE of 15 that gives you $16.20.

    But this a low-ball estimate as ETFC is paying down their debt at an accelerated rate and this estimate also understates ETFC’s true growth potential as being the best on-line trading platform hands-down.

    $1.08/share could easily double by 2011.

    Now you’re looking at a $32.40 share price, or least something in between $16.20 - $32.40.

    This target will be reached before 2011, of course, as the market tends to race to true valuations prior to actual earnings materializing.

    Also AMTD & other companies interested in acquiring ETFC are well aware of how rapidly ETFC share price is going to appreciate and have a vested interest in naked shorting the crap out of the stock down to levels that would make a cheap buyout offer appear reasonable.

    (THIS HAPPENS ALL THE TIME)

    So either way, short-term ETFC gets acquired for a decent return for shareholders, ($8.00 - $12.00) or she doesn’t get bought and appreciates on her own upwards toward $16.00 - $32.00 over the next 18 - 24 month.

    The naked shorties know what this company is going to be worth and they want as many of your shares as they can possibly scrounge.

  3. cabz

    Given that traffic for e-trade comes from various channels, and demand for their services depends on demand for financial services in general, this example doesn’t seem to offer much, if any, value.

    For example:

    Did you compare their traffic to other online trading or banking companies to try to determine if traffic may have decreased as a result of market sentiment (or anything else for that matter)? Did you consider that existing customers probably have more ‘velocity’, and that if new customers aren’t showing up, their velocity would likely increase by default?


Have something to say? Leave a Comment

Get the comments RSS feed, instant notification of new comments

Latest Blog Posts:


Sep 5: Battle for the Online Box Office: Fandango and MovieTickets
Sep 4: July Online Video Market Share: YouTube Marches On, Crackle Gets Major Push From Minisodes
Sep 3: The “New” Facebook: Learning From Old Mistakes
Sep 2: Where Have All the Clickthroughs Gone?
Aug 29: ING DIRECT vs. E*TRADE: Seeing Inside Your Rival’s Ads
Aug 28: Interview with Presentation Zen Master Garr Reynolds
Aug 27: Guest Post: How Are Hyundai’s Strengths Transferring Across Vehicle Categories?
Aug 26: What Else are iPhone Researchers Into? Blogging and Travel Sites
Aug 25: July Search Market Share Update: Everyone Dips But Google
Aug 22: Yahoo! Takes Gold in Olympic Reach, NBC Squeaks Win in Engagement
Aug 21: Forget Bush Fatigue, Obama Fatigue is Here (To Stay?)
Aug 20: The iPhone Comes to Best Buy: Good Buy or Good-Bye for Consumers?
Aug 19: Kruger: A Battle of Might, Will… What Were We Talking About?
Aug 18: The Mass Affluent and the Economy
Aug 15: Superhero… Phones? Cell Phone Microsites Ride the Hype of Big Summer Movies
Aug 14: Borders.com Now in Control of its Own Destiny
Aug 13: Is Circuit City Making a Comeback, or is Best Buy #1 Online?
Aug 12: The Dark Knight: Is the Knight of the Box-Office Also the Knight of Online Search?
Aug 11: Priceline Guarantees Sunshine, Gets Conversion
Aug 8: Olympics Online: ESPN, Yahoo!, NBC Battling for Gold