If any industry has felt the brunt of the internet as a disruptive technology, it’s the music industry, which has been dealt a heavy blow by the onset of digital music distribution. On the April 28, the RIAA again confirmed this state of affairs when reporting that CD sales, the mainstay of the business for the last 15 years, were down a whopping 20.5% in 2007. Then on May 2, a Federal Court ordered AOL, Real Networks and Yahoo! to pay $100M to music artists as back payment for streaming their music online, proving that it’s not just the Big Four labels who have been affected by this disruptive shift.

Apple, a technology company, has become the most powerful player, with sales of 2 billion songs last year. The iPod/iTunes combo, the default of cool in our culture, has freaked out the Big Four and sent traditional music retailers like Wal-Mart and web 1.0 giants like Amazon scrambling into digital music distribution. So far their nascent incursions have not had a big impact, despite offering DRM-free music and savings of a few pennies.

While Apple and other legal download options have somewhat offset declining CD sales, the industry carries far too much overhead from 60 years of jacked up prices to make the digital transition smoothly. Music buyers used to pay up to $18 for an album and rarely was every song a keeper, now they pay 99 cents a drink.

Moreover, many consumers don’t pay for music at any price. The chart below, based on Compete’s data on more than 1,000 music sites, shows how the most popular options for listening to music online are free.

Despite lawsuits against illegal download sites, the fastest growing category in online music last year was P2P downloads, which shot up 140%. Nearly ten years after Napster raged through college networks, online music piracy continues to grow.

Meanwhile, the largest category in online music in March, 2008 was streaming, which racked up 28M unique visitors. The portals have driven the category’s dominance for many years by plugging into their massive traffic bases. MySpace joined the top ranks in 2005.

Then in 2007, a new breed of Web 2.0 sites with sleek, bright graphics and deep search and social feature integration, began to spread virally through social networks and heavily-linked music blogs. The sites combine streaming music with community-based sharing (vs. the anonymous exchange at P2P download sites) and in doing so can skirt thorny legal download issues.

These social streaming communities have risen rapidly in popularity. iMeem recently overtook Yahoo! Music as the most popular streaming site on the web.

*The Hypem1500 presents aggregate traffic to the more than 1500 music blogs tracked by the Hype Machine, a popular blog aggregator. The Hype Machine itself is ranked separately from its network at #16.

Collectively, the social streaming communities are flattening out the curve of online music. Compared to a year ago, the distribution of unique visitors at the Top 25 Streaming sites has a more gradual drop-off and longer tail.

As the music industry seeks to reassemble in the wake of digital distribution, it should recognize social streaming communities as the fastest growing opportunity in its evolution.

**UPDATE**
Since the original post, we received great feedback from MySpace who provided the urls of music streaming beyond music.myspace.com, and we wanted to share those numbers. After we ran Compete data on the expanded set of urls, we found that its aggregate volume for music-streaming unique visitors is 19.2 million.

The data from the post included only the subdomain traffic of some sites, and does not represent all of their on-site streaming activity. This relates to some of the larger brands like MySpace, AOL, and Yahoo! who have more urls beyond the subdomains listed where consumers can stream music.

We encourage discussion on our blog and additional perspectives on the evolving online music space.


Analyze more domains: + +

Done reading? subscribe: To get an automatic feed of all future posts subscribe here, or to receive them via email enter your email address in the box in the right column.

Link to This Post:     


Comments

RSS feed for comments on this post.
  1. Jaan Kanellis

    The music industry deserves all the losses they are incurring. We should only pay for the music we want and we now finally have a system in which we can do so.

  2. Ling

    You know, I don’t see youtube anywhere in that list. I realize we’re talking about music, not video, but still, why don’t you just search for a song you want to listen to in youtube, and see if you can find it? Do you have any data about the number of people who simply listen/watch music videos on youtube?

  3. Still Rob G

    Ling: have you looked at imeem.com? it is esentially youtube for music, upload mp3’s and share them like you upload videos to youtube, I uderstand there are users who fake their mp3’s it videos to upload them to youtube, but I imagine that’s partly because imeem still isn’t the household name that youtube is. Imeem also does video, but I think that’s a small part of its traffic. I hear that many of the original engineers that built imeem came from the original napster.

    So all the sites which were part of the first internet boom have lost traffic, almost all the web 2.0 sites, with the exception of projectplaylist and myspace, are either new entries or have grown in traffic.

  4. Greg

    For the record, Yahoo, RealNetworks and AOL may have to eventually pay ASCAP up to $100 million, but that’s only ASCAP’s estimate - the court never gave a final figure for the period going back to 2002, and the Digital Media Association called the estimate a shot in the dark.

  5. Lx7 - The Something In That Square

    The Low Down on Streaming Music

    Complete.com put together a list of the top 20 Streaming Music Sites with a year comparison to their 2007. The article: The Rise of Social Streaming gives a decent overview of the music consumer numbers cross most digital access points. But what I f…

  6. David Porter

    Great stuff, Alex. I’ve been using compete.com to periodically track the top music sites. There’s a few that you may want to pick up for completeness. Check out http://davidporter.wordpress.com/2008/04/06/top-25-music-sites-march-2008/.

  7. Social Marketing Journal

    The music industry will never go back to what it was. The overpriced albums made the average listener rebel. It’s just a shame when the hard working musicians lose out.

  8. littleguy47

    hey everyone i want to post my email which is littleguy47@gmail.com and see how many people get on it and please do not change the password i just want to see how many people i can get to get on it just dont change the password and when you get on send an email to littleguy47@gmail.com and say you got on and the password is cougar22
    just please dont change the password
    -littleguy47
    oh and post this EVERYWHERE and send it to EVERYBODY you know!!!!
    this i gonna be sweet

  9. David

    Illuminating entry, thanks!

    For those who want to think about the songs again and not just everything around them, check out http://jamsbio.com and share your memories of music!

  10. regeln von poker

    online poker play money

    Cours online casino betrug play poker texas jueces casinos pai gow poker pagina internet realistische online spielbank

  11. noodle

    littleguy47
    I’m totally changing the password

  12. Webdoc

    You missed Shoutcast, which at this moment has 586,786 listeners, easily putting it in the top 10.

  13. AudioPhil

    I’m through buying and listening to commercial music. It all sounds like it came from the same source. My ears like to hear authentic independents like Len Francis Monahan or one of those guys. Bob Dylan still sounds authentic but not always. Genuinely creative songs like Monahan’s “Voice of the Guitar” brings joy to me.
    http://www.amazon.com/Voice-Of-The-Guitar/dp/B00160Y5MC/ref=sr_f2_9?ie=UTF8&s=dmusic&qid=1213312007&sr=102-9


Have something to say? Leave a Comment

Get the comments RSS feed, instant notification of new comments

Latest Blog Posts:


Jul 18: Online Financial Services Monthly Performance Update for May 2008
Jul 17: Are Social Conservatives Starting to Fall in Line Behind John McCain?
Jul 16: June Search Market Share Update: Windows Live Search Marketing Kicks In
Jul 15: YouTube: MTV On Demand
Jul 14: Manchester United, Juventus, Liverpool All Winners in the U.S. Online Game
Jul 11: June Top Movers - Foxes and Tigers and Buzz… Oh my!
Jul 10: Will the Blackberry Bold Keep RIM Customers from Churning to Apple?
Jul 9: Can Unified Communications Solutions Become More Popular Than the Pipe That Enables Them?
Jul 8: Check out June Data on Compete Site Analytics!
Jul 8: State of the Auto Insurance Market: An Interview with Jon Swallen of TNS Media Intelligence
Jul 7: Which PGA Tour Sponsor is Getting the Biggest Benefit Online?
Jul 3: TripAdvisor Poised For Success
Jul 2: Zillow Unveils New “Mortgage Marketplace” Offering
Jul 1: Moviegoers Online: The Wisdom of Crowds and the Web
Jun 30: What You Have Been Asking For… Today We Are Launching Compete PRO and Ranked Lists!
Jun 27: E*Trade: The Right Stuff “Baby”?
Jun 26: May Online Video Market Share: ABC Signs Up With Veoh; Fancast and Hulu Tango
Jun 25: Interview with Analytics Evangelist Avinash Kaushik (Part 2 of 2)
Jun 24: Compete on Fox Business: Discussing Campaign Finance
Jun 24: Interview with Analytics Evangelist Avinash Kaushik (part 1 of 2)