Our readers have had several questions regarding the June Search Share, specifically MSN/Live’s increase and we have posted an update, showing the numbers without the ClubLive traffic. Check it out!

Google finally has a competitor join it in the (until now) exclusive, positive-year-over-year-growth club. MSN/Live increased their query volume by 67% from May, and 48% from a year ago. Search volume was up all across the board in June and took most everyone else in the same direction.

A good portion of the additional Live searches are coming from the Live Search Club, where you can apparently play games for points which you can redeem for fine Microsoft products. All of the games involve using Live’s search engine – to get the points, you have to search with Live. It looks like Chicktionary is leading the charge (by the way, “chicktionary”… not as cool as it sounds).

We didn’t see any traffic to club.live.com at all in April. About a third of a million unique visitors went to the club in May, and in June, this shot up to over 3 million unique visitors.

While that sharp spike from MSN looks impressive, it’s only relative to their own current standing. In terms of market share, it represents just 5 percentage points that Live took away from other engines (mostly Google). If Microsoft can actually leverage this traffic to club.live.com into actual search users and string together a few more months like this, they could really threaten Google’s top spot.

Share - Save - E-mail


Analyze more domains: + +

Done reading? subscribe: To get an automatic feed of all future posts subscribe here, or to receive them via email enter your email address in the box in the right column.

Link to This Post:     


Comments

RSS feed for comments on this post.
  1. Cliff Parker

    This seems wrong to me. Why would MSN take 4.3 points of share only from Google, but only 0.1 points from Yahoo and 0.2 points from Ask? If anything, Google users strike me as less likely to switch to Live — and certainly to Club Live — than Yahoo or Ask users. Also, search market shares usually move by tenths of percentage points per month. A move this big in one month is unprecedented. Are you sure your data are correct?

  2. TanNg

    #1. Because Yahoo, Ask generate search from contents, Google from direct search.

  3. Leonard E.

    How does one independently verify that Compete, Inc. is impartial and unbiased ?

    How do we know that you are not being funded by or biased towards one or more of the major search engines?

    How does Compete, Inc. pay its bills?

    Thanks for any response

  4. funvin

    Cliff, you are assuming that the total search queries remained constant.
    What might have happen is total search queries went up by say ~12%, of which say 4% went to live, 7% went to yahoo, 0.6% went to ask, and only 0.4% went to google. So google infact gained 0.4% more queries, possibly with no one switching. But still its % share of market declined since other players gained a larger share of the increase in queries.

  5. Michael Santora

    Cliff Parker asked, “A move this big in one month is unprecedented. Are you sure your data are correct?”

    As a club live player, and a participant in various message boards regarding these games, I can offer my opinion that this enormous increase in traffic makes perfect sense. Each time one plays one of these club live games, it racks up dozens of search engine hits, and a game might take 5 minutes. So hundreds of hits per hour. And some of the prizes are so lucrative (for example, a $400 retail version of Windows Vista in exchange for maybe 10 hours of playing games, now that the solutions to all the puzzles have been posted in various places), people play hour after hour after hour. I know of people who have already won 10 or 20 copies of Windows Vista.

    In addition, there has been significant amounts of “botting” going on, people running bots which play the games for them. A single one of these people can be generating tens of thousands of search engine hits over time.

    I was expecting to see a big jump in the search engine numbers, and so I’m not surprised at all.

  6. Cliff Parker

    To Funvin’s point, I don’t see why only Google would have had a meaningful market share change. If Club Live were really expanding the search market, Yahoo and Ask should have seen more share loss.

    Also, why are we counting “searches” from Live Search Club as searches? I just played Chicktionary, and what it does is run a search every time you enter a word into the game. My guess is that at least 90% of the “searches” run by Chicktionary aren’t even viewed by the customer.

    Compete, I’m still skeptical of your data. Can you explain why Live Search Club had a big impact on Google but not on Yahoo and Ask?

  7. Michael Martinez

    Every month I have to estimate Query-To-Visitor ratios for the search engines to track real market share. It would make life more interesting (and your statistics more useful) if you guys would do it for the rest of us. Number-of-Queries per month and Number-of-visitors per month don’t tell us anything useful about the search market.

  8. Coffee Games

    Can we see the exact same chart but with the Live Search Club metrics removed?

  9. Michael

    Obviously some people are feeling kind of zealous that Windows Live is taking up a slightly more higher percentage of market share. Face it, Live Search Club is popular. Just play some games, win some points, and trade it for some neat prizes on the site. That’s good marketing there.

    For the most part, the results are usually relevant. For me. You could even find the answer just by looking at the results and their descriptions. It’s pretty easy. I’m not sure if it’s going to get any Google switchers, but it could. Live Search is actually pretty good in some parts if you tried it. Like Instant Answers are neat. Overall, there’s not much difference in relevancy across all search engines. It’s just the branding that gets people. I was expecting Live Search Club to drive up market share, and I guess I was right.

  10. Trevor Ginn

    It does not surprise me that the market share went from Yahoo and ask and not Google. If people haven’t given up using those search engines yet, they are probably pretty devoted to them!

  11. Jeff Drentlin

    I never heard of Live Search Club before reading this article. It did prompt me to join and give Microsoft a hand at cracking Google!

  12. Charlie Foster

    Well, the author said it right in the first few sentences. MSN/Live has increased their search traffic, and the searches mostly come from Live Search Club.

    Smoke and mirrors… how can anyone look at this data and say MSN/Live has actually increased their search market share? They just added games where the page automatically queries a new word, and then they count it as a search. People are just playing games, not searching for keywords. Are you kidding me? It seems like an attempt to make it look like they’re making a run for it and create some publicity. I guess any search engine could have a program running searches for you automatically and then declare an increase in search traffic.

    This data means nothing.

  13. StephenDiMarco

    Thanks to everyone for your comments – whenever another company makes headway against Google its a big deal! I thought I would answer some of the questions that came up in your comments:

    Cliff asks why Google took the market share hit, while Yahoo and Ask increased (and then questioned the accuracy of our data). The mathematical answer is that total query volume across the four engines grew about 7%. Since Google query volume was largely flat from May-June, its share naturally decreased; the Yahoo and Ask query growth were independent of the Club Live phenomenon, but not enough to increase share. Club Live *helped* Microsoft grow faster than the market so it was the only engine who increased share (in a growing market). And yes our data are accurate.

    Leonard E. asks if anyone can vouch that we are impartial, favorable to one engine or another and how we pay our bills. In this order: 1) our userbase (compete.com users and our vertical market clients) will vouch that our data is an unbiased representation of web traffic, and that our methodology is statistically sound. We would be out of business if they weren’t; 2) we’re not biased toward any one company; like Switzerland, our data and our findings are market neutral; 3) we pay our bills on time. Ok, seriously, we work with big marketing clients in the automotive, telcom/media, travel and financial services markets – and engines and portals; they pay our bills, but we do a great job separating search and state if you’re worried that a client relationship might sway our “investigative reporting.”

    Coffee Games asks if we can show the same table with Club Live data removed. Your wish is our command. Steve Willis is posting that information today on the Compete blog. Check back early afternoon.

    Let me know if there are any questions. I’ll try to answer them as clearly as possible. Keep in mind, answering math problems with prose is one of the harder challenges in life (and funvin is better than me at it).

  14. Michael

    @Charlie Foster: The data does mean something. It means that more people are using Live Search. Live Search might be a viable alternative to Google for some users if they try it long enough. Live Search Club isn’t meant to generate more search market-share, it was meant for people to give Live Search a try, possibly trade in points for prizes, and possibly even get real switchers to that platform.

    All in all, it’s kind of ingenious.

  15. Jack Spirko

    This is pretty easy to understand. MS, sells 40 Million copies of Vista, this resets default search functions or most of those users, MS search share rockets. Oh gee, wow! Come on this is not hard to understand, give it a month or so it won’t last.

  16. Microsoft News Tracker

    Microsoft buys search share with Live Search Club

    Bill Gates famously suggested that Microsoft might buy the affections of Internet searchers and that seems to have come true as market research firms Compete and comScore have both reported a substantial jump in Microsoft’s June US search share …

  17. hassan wali

    name : hassan mohmmed ali wali
    city : sudia arbia lshrqia
    address: alkhopar alkornish north
    jawwal internatonal : 009663508433023
    jawwal out site city : 03508433023
    jawwal in site city ?: 0508433023

  18. Cam Lover

    msn live will do it to us all

  19. sheds

    MSN should re-think their search result since still msn not deliver quality result to user with compare to google.com

  20. trademark registration

    Interesting results. Thanks for posting.

  21. Thorsten Engel

    Wow i was looking for the lyrics to la coupe de boule because i loved it when i heard it and i wanted to know what it meant so thanks! Your translation is awesome :)

  22. Kit Homes

    MSN should definetly re-think their search result since they do not deliver quality result to compare with google.com

  23. Brandie

    Brandie

    This enables authors to keep track of who is linking to, or referring to their articles. Many blogs have stopped using trackbacks because

  24. balimcafe

    http://www.balimcafe.net

  25. samyeli

    http://www.muhabbetgulu.com

  26. dinisohbet

    thanks

  27. islamisohbet

    thanks

  28. prefabrik

    thanks

  29. gaziantep evden eve nakliyat

    thanks you

  30. gaziantep evden eve tasimacilik

    thanks you very good

  31. Azot

    Интересный пост, спасибо вам. Меня интересует вопрос – будет ли продолжение? :)

  32. БaйaчaБeбe

    Даа… :) Вы бы знали что про Вас пишут в других блогах :)

  33. islamkenti

    thank

  34. تصميم

    thaankekss

  35. islamiyet

    islamiyet thanks…..


Have something to say? Leave a Comment

Get the comments RSS feed, instant notification of new comments

Latest Blog Posts:


Feb 9: Truth in Engineering… and Marketing
Feb 8: Doppelganger Week Turns To Urban Dictionary
Feb 5: The Role of Search in the Online Deposits Market
Feb 4: Conan vs. Leno: Coco Must Go
Feb 3: Oscar Mayer Brings Good Mood
Feb 2: Compete Ranks December’s Top Food and Cooking Sites
Feb 1: Travel Industry Rebound Based on Site Traffic: The Other Side of the Coin
Jan 29: The Nexus One – Google’s Next (But Likely Not Final) Frontier
Jan 29: Search is Integral to Driving a Wave of Cruise Bookings
Jan 28: Compete’s CMO on Audience Insights, Not Audience Measurement
Jan 27: Consumers Slow to Embrace Social Media As Shopping Resource
Jan 26: Online Food Fight: Scripps vs. Cablevision
Jan 25: List of Top 50 Websites in December 2009
Jan 22: Setting My Sights on Site-to-Store
Jan 21: Compete Now Offers Audience Insights!
Jan 14: Can shipping costs affect online sales?
Jan 11: My 10 year MSN Hotmail anniversary and what it means to Gmail
Jan 8: World War 3G
Jan 7: A look under the hood of Ad Impact
Jan 5: Smartphone Owners Now Spending More from Handset, but Poor Site Functionality Is a Turn-off