Buy.com hunting in the Amazon: Part I
Written by TJ Mahony (contact - e-mail) -- August 29th, 2006 | Recommend ThisI will admit, the motivation of this article was ignorance. A few months ago I noticed a TV commercial where the CEO of Buy.com is standing on the roof of his headquarters toting Buy.com’s promotion of “10% off Amazon.com prices”. I sat on my couch thinking, “done! I’ll just buy all my stuff at Buy.com from now on”. However, my trick ear was acting up and I had simply misinterpreted his message - it was 10% of in-stock books, not the breadth of Buy.com’s inventory. Regardless, my confusion led me to briefly abandon my beloved Amazon, thus I’m wondering how many other people did the same.
Buy.com’s “10% off Amazon.com prices” promotion officially began on September 12th, 2005. We decided to look at traffic from January ‘05 and monitor the relative growth of Amazon and Buy.com before and after the promotion began. We indexed all traffic to January ‘05 levels.
In the coveted holiday months of November and December Buy.com traffic grew relatively faster compared to Amazon. Whereas Amazon only showed relative growth of 22% and 38% compared to January ‘05, Buy.com exhibited growth rates of 32% and 54%, respectively.
This is not to say Buy.com overtook Amazon during last year’s holiday season. In fact, Amazon attracted 52M U.S. visitors last December, compared to only 2.8M at Buy.com. Yes, Buy.com has a long way to go before they can be considered an equal peer of Amazon’s; however their promotion appears to have yielded a small win during last year’s holiday season.
In terms of conversion rate, Buy.com’s campaign had a minimal effect. In fact, the majority of Buy.com’s conversion improvements, relative to Amazon, occurred before the campaign was launched.
To what extent has the “10% off Amazon.com prices” contributed to Buy.com resurgence? Given the ultra dynamic retail market it’s never safe to directly attribute success to a single promotion; however it’s clear the promotion has not hurt Buy.com’s performance. Immediately after launching the campaign Buy.com increased the percentage of Amazon visitors evaluating buy.com for three straight months. When Buy.com initiated the promotion in September ‘05 they announced the promotion would only last four months, yet as of August 14th (11 months later) the promotion is still available and aggressively promoted on Buy.com’s homepage.
Either my curiosity or my pride has the better of me and I want to dig a little deeper on this promotion. To satisfy my curiosity Compete will interview members who have shopped at both Amazon and Buy.com and understand their intentions, motivations and attitudes between the two retailers. Stay tuned….
Did you like that post? You'll love these.
Done reading? subscribe: To get an automatic feed of all future posts subscribe here, or to receive them via email enter your email address in the box in the right column.
Link to This Post:
Posted under: Finance - Real Estate - Stocks, Head2Head Battles, Retail |
Trackback Link | Permalink | 
Get the 
August 29th, 2006 at 11:38 am
Thanks for that, fascinating stuff.
How a sale really affects the bottom line - especially for the whole industry - is an important thing to know. This data shows how pent-up demand by bargain hunters waiting for such an event to get off the dime (or being convinced to splurge by such an event) wears off over time.
The use of the internet to help master the time element of this phenom has always seemed to me to be the biggest potential advantage to e-tailing. That has not been realized yet, however. buy.com still advertises on teevee, for example.
That alone has convinced me that the “paradigm shift” talked about so much in 1999 wasn’t nearly what everyone said.
August 29th, 2006 at 12:31 pm
There’s nothing AMZN offers that anyone else can’t…product reviews? You can go to Amazon, read the reviews and buy elsewhere. And any product with a good number of reviews will have several people who can’t live without it and several who threw it right away.
October 4th, 2006 at 9:45 pm
i’m wondering how do u know the conversion of amazon and buy.com???
October 5th, 2006 at 11:01 am
Abow,
Compete has developed a unique methodology created by experts in the fields of mathematics, statistics and the data sciences to aggregate, transform, enhance and normalize data in order to estimate U.S. internet traffic.
Based on anonymous daily web usage of more than 2 million people (and growing!), Compete calculates total traffic and rank for nearly every site on the web. We use rigorous statistics to make sure our estimates balance demographic and connection factors that match the entire U.S. Internet population. For now, we only calculate the number of people in the U.S. that visit any given website each month (international usage calculations are in development).
We estimate traffic to the pageview level, which makes it possible for us to calculate conversion rates and analyze conversion funnels for almost all websites.
Hope this answered your question.
Best,
The Compete Team
March 29th, 2007 at 2:42 am
AdSense Money Maker
Do you know how to make money from AdSense automatically? You don’t!? I’ll teach you how!